9/11/2019 4:23:28 PM

Ambiguity

James DeBoer / 1 Comment

 

   Ambiguity - "the quality of being open to more than one interpretation; inexactness" (Oxford)

   I find it one of the most attractive things a painting can hold. It can be that the work presents more than one interpretation at the same time and the work can never be completely defined. Or it may be a portrayal of one concept, one thing, but in a way that is indistinct, not fully laid out for us, the viewers, and we must struggle in our minds to complete the picture. It's these kind of paintings that draw me back to a museum to see them again and again, and perhaps you as well.

 

   If everything I've said so far is, itself, ambiguous, then let me show you a couple of paintings. This is, after all, one of the purposes of painting, to show in a picture that which cannot be put well into words.

 

   One of my favorites is Picasso's "The Old Guitarist", which hangs in Chicago's Art Institute. Unfortunately, what is barely visible in reproductions such as above, is the presence of the woman in the painting. She stands behind him, her eyes just above the nape of his neck. The painting has been x-rayed, and the experts tell us that The Old Guitarist is painted over a previous painting containing the woman, and that Picasso was simply reusing an old canvas. In that case, he was sloppy, not doing a very good job of covering over the underlying woman. 

But when I stand in front of the actual work, I see where the woman's neck and the guitarist's neck overlap and that Picasso colored the woman's neck a different shade of blue from the guitarist's neck, as though to emphasize her as actually part of the painting we see.

 

   So, Ambiguity #1: Is the presence of the woman in this painting incidental and not really supposed to be there? Or did Picasso reuse the old canvas, and seeing the woman's image seeping through, decide, "I think I'll keep her" and put the lighter shade of blue on her neck? Or perhaps he planned to have her in the picture from the start.

Ambiguity #2: If not just an accident, who then is the woman? Apparently someone the guitarist has on his mind as he picks up his instrument; and old love, a wife, a singer he used to accompany?

 

   All of these interpretations fight with each other in my mind, and I am constantly drawn back to this painting like a bee to honey, unable to resolve them.

 

   In one of my own paintings, I have tried to capture the quality of ambiguity. That is "Edge" (above, pastel, 22" x 30"), which was shown at the International Association of Pastel Societies juried show in Brea, CA, a few years back.  While making this painting, the image kept shifting on me: something growing viewed under a microscope? or the surface of a distant planet? or the winds of a desert uncovering the remains of an ancient civilization? There is clearly a difference between the left side of the painting and the right, but where is the actual edge between them? There is no sharp dividing line.

 

   This is like so many things in human experience. We know where things are, generally, but can't exactly say where one stops and another begins. We know what is ocean and what is is land, but where is the exact line between them? The highest reach of the waves? The lowest? At high or low tide? Somewhere in between? Or the line between right and wrong? Some things seem clearly always right or always wrong, but one can usually think of a situation that seems to be an exception and crosses over the line between right and wrong. Although the centers of these categories are clear, the edges are blurry, and therein lies the interest.

 

   Do you have any favorite paintings that possess and indistinctness or ambiguity that you find attractive and draw you to them?

Read More

3/5/2017 11:59:44 AM

Portraying Celebrities: Rosalba Carriera

James DeBoer / 1 Comment

   Rosalba Carriera of Venice was  the first of the great 18th Century pastelists. In the early 1700's, she won fame for pastel portraits of the celebrated ladies of Venice, and in 1720, she was invited Paris. There, she was welcomed as one of the greatest artists of the time and elected to the French Academy of Painting. King Louis XV sat for her. She and Antoine Watteau painted each other and poets lauded her. In 1730, she traveled to Vienna where, among other notables, she painted the portrait of Maria Theresa, who soon became the great Empress of the Habsburg Empire.

   Her pastel portraits, at least the ones I have seen in the Art Institute of Chicago, appear to be done on a soft paper, which allows for smooth blending with a paper stump or fingertip (see detail below). She takes full advantage of the matte surface of pastels - no shine or glare as with oils. The skin is soft this way, and the textures of the aristocratic silk, satin and jewels are displayed to their fullest. I have include below, from among her many, many portraits, "Young Woman with Parrot" and "The Singer Faustina Boldini with a Musical Score."

   At variance with her her flattering portrayals of the royal and famous is her own self-portrait (below, last), done in older age, in a more realist approach. In contrast, the look is somber, the colors muted.

   This makes me interested in Rosalba. What was she really like? As a painter of the stars, the celebrities of her time, she apparently didn't buy into their rosy, fashionable world, but keep a more critical view of things when she applied them to herself. Her subjects, like those of a modern celebrity photographer, are in the most fashionable clothes and jewelry, the women with provocative, low-cut necklines. Ms. Boldini's exposure is intentional, not a wardrobe malfunction.

   But what did Rosalba really think? Wouldn't you like to interview her? "Painter of Royalty and Stars of the Music World Tells All!" Would she tell all? Or would she keep that lifetime of secrets to herself, both her own secrets and those of her sitters? When asked, would she, as in her self-portrait, just tighten her lips a bit, avert her eyes, and think the answers to herself? Does she look tired? Or is that, more with the eyes  than with her mouth, a faint Mona Lisa smile?

 

Read More

2/26/2017 12:25:47 PM

Great Pastelists - Whistler

James DeBoer / Comment on this

James Abbott McNeill Whistler was not only a great painter and etcher (see previous blog on his etchings), but also a brilliant pastelist. During the resurgence of pastel painting in the later 19th Century, most of the artists piled on the pastel strokes thick and bright. Degas' ballet dancers are a good example. Whistler took the opposite tack and put a minimal amount of color on, usually, brownish paper, just highlighting the skeleton of an underlying drawing. At first glance, they appear hurried, like a preliminary sketch for a later painting, but after looking more carefully, one can see them as the finished works they are.The bulk of his pastels were done in Venice, 1879-80, also the time he completed a large portfolio of etchings. A couple of these Venetian pastels are included below.

 

Additionally, he did a number of portraits of women in pastel, and like many of the women in his oil paintings, they appear ethereal, in their own space, with a minimum of background or props cluttering the scene.

 

Read More

2/18/2017 12:36:43 PM

Thomas Cole and the Romantic Landscape

James DeBoer / Comment on this

When the Enlightenment wound down at the end of the 18th Century, with its clockwork world running smoothly according to scientific laws and with society and government under the control of rational thought, it was replaced by what art historian Kenneth Clark called "The Romantic Rebellion".

 

The landscape art of the Enlightenment era was labeled the Beautiful, and tended toward the idyllic: peaceful, neoclassic landscapes with gods and goddesses, nymphs and satyrs, or biblical figures, often among ruins of castles or Greek temples, basking in diffuse light. An example from Claude Lorrain is below, "Argus Guarding Io".

 

With the Romantic era came the other extreme, the Sublime. This attempted to bring out the emotions of awe and terror at the irrational, destructive force of nature: battered trees, raging storms, avalanches, shipwrecks. It was the opposite of Enlightenment rationality, and fore- shadowed the Apocalypse at the end of the world. An example is below, "An Avalanche in the Alps" by Phillip James De Loutherbourg.

 

But the romantics also introduced the Picturesque, the third category of artistic expression at that time. The picturesque landscape was rugged and wild: virgin forests, wild rivers, waterfalls, unexplored mountains, that is, the American wilderness. The Picturesque engaged the viewer with the idylls of the Beautiful as well as the awe (but not the terror) of the Sublime. Unlike the Beautiful, which was imaginative, the Picturesque was objective. It painted what was there before the eye (with, often, a little added makeup), the choice of subject and the artist's technique making of it a picturesque work of art.

 

Enter the English-born American, Thomas Cole, who found exactly this landscape in the Catskill Mountains and the Hudson River Valley. His pursuit of the picturesque in New York led to the American art movement of the early and mid-19th Century called the Hudson River School. One of his paintings of the Genesee River is below. His immediate artistic heirs included Sanford Gifford and Frederick Church, the latter of whom also painted the South American landscape. The third generation of Albert Bierstadt and Thomas Moran took the picturesque west to the Rocky Mountains.

 

 

Read More

1/28/2017 4:29:41 PM

Great Printmakers: Anselm Kiefer

James DeBoer / Comment on this

This being an approximately weekly commentary on great pastelists, great printmakers, art as bearing witness, problems in the making of art, and such.

 

I saw the most amazing set of woodcuts! This was at a show last spring at the Albertina in Vienna, Austria. I am used to working on prints that are more or less the size of a book page, no bigger than, say, 15". The first striking thing about German artist Anselm Kiefer's work is the scale - works that are up to 10 to 12 feet in size, one of which can take up an entire gallery wall! These are assembled. That is, his large pieces of cut wood are printed and the works then put together as collage.

 

The second thing that impressed me was his successful manipulation of abstract themes. Kiefer's work explores several of these: German mythology and the failures it has brought his country, ideas made all the more weighty by the monumental size of the works. But he also works with themes of hope and the essence of being human, whether a self-portrait lying under a starry sky or with a sunflower growing up out of his body.

 

Two of his works are below: "The Starry Sky Above Me and the Moral Law Within Me" (the body is life size), and "Hortus Conclusus".

Read More

1/22/2017 1:22:07 PM

Soul Portraits

James DeBoer / Comment on this

My last two blogs were a bit "dark", so this time I'm going to a subject more innocent, Soul Portraits.

 

One of the biggest difficulties in making abstract art is producing works that have some sort of content, are about something of some sort and are not just interior decorating. The originators of abstract art, such as Wassily Kandinsky, Kasimir Malevich, or Arthur Dove all struggled with this, and Kandinsky even wrote books on the subject.

 

Most of my work is realist, but when I do tackle abstraction, I will often warm up for it by taking a couple of poems and trying imagine illustrations for them. Like many people, I love/hate poetry, and the more abstract the poem, the more I like the challenge of drawing a picture of it. This led me to do a set of portraits of peoples' souls. They were done as black ink mono prints, meaning that the original print plate image is destroyed in the process of making the one print.

 

The souls illustrated are not of any specific person, but you might, nevertheless, see yourself in one of them (I'm a #2).

 

Read More

1/16/2017 4:03:29 PM

Art Bearing Witness III

James DeBoer / Comment on this

Being an approximately weekly commentary on great pastelists, great printmakers, art as bearing witness, problems in the making of art, and such.

 

Otto Dix was a German painter and printmaker. Born in 1891, he became part of the World War I generation of soldiers. He was age 22 when the war started and he volunteered becoming a machine-gunner in the battle of the Somme, helping to defend German lines against the advance of the British, who incidentally included C. S. Lewis and J. R. R. Tolkien. He was wounded several times on the front, once nearly fatally, and all this hospital time gave him the opportunity to closely observe the wounded and dying. He kept a diary and a sketch book of his experiences.

 

Dix was traumatized by the war, suffering persistent nightmares. he produced a series of 50 prints, simply called "The War", charting the effect of the war on individual soldiers.

 

Like many artists and writers of his generation from both sides, the war had left him disillusioned about the cynical manipulation of patriotism and the portrayal of war as heroic. During the lead-up to and during World War II, he was harassed by the Nazis who still wanted war displayed as patriotic and heroic. His work was entered on Hitler's list of Entartete Kunst, or Degenerate Art. Nevertheless, he muddled through the war and painted until his death in Dresden in 1969.

 

Read More

1/9/2017 10:05:52 AM

Art Bearing Witness II

James DeBoer / Comment on this

   In a previous post, I had commented on the frequent desire of artists to produce work that changes the world, but how rarely that actually happens. In that case I had mentioned the exception of Thomas Moran, whose Yellowstone paintings helped persuade Congress to preserve the Yellowstone country, inventing the national park system, a concept later adopted by other countries around the world. This setting aside of nature "for all time" probably marks the beginning of the Green Movement.

 

   A little less rarely, we experience the role of art as, if not changing the world, at least bearing witness to what is going on.

 

   One of the first and best to do this was Francisco Goya, who provided the first visual record of human rights abuses in his print series, "The Disasters of War". This was a set of approximately 80 etchings based on the atrocities committed by the Napoleonic Army during their invasion of Spain, beginning in 1808. These images include rape, torture, summary executions, mass graves, and starvation (20,000 died of famine in Madrid alone). Many of the plates are considered to be Goya's eyewitness accounts. He produced these between 1810 and 1820, but did not dare publish them in his lifetime, continuing his day job of producing portraits for those who could afford portraits.

 

   War art, until and during this time, was always heroic, and Goya's "Disasters" were anything but.  Even the "victors", the French soldiers, often appear faceless, dehumanized by their own actions. These prints did not reach the public until the 1860's, long after Goya's death. Although they were not seen by the generation that experienced the horrors of this war, they are a perpetual witness to the generations following.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Read More

11/14/2015 11:20:22 AM

Thomas Moran and Changing the World

James DeBoer / Comment on this

 

It doesn't happen often, but occasionally a younger artist will confide in me a wish to create a painting "that will change the world." Perhaps we have all dreamed of that at some time, but find instead that the works we produce are valued for their beauty or are simply regarded as a luxury good, rather than being valued as a challenge to the usual ways of thinking.

 

In fact, it is hard to think of many paintings that did influence any history outside of the history of art. Theodore Gericault's "The Raft of the Medusa" comes to mind because it caused a great political stir in the Paris of 1819, but ultimately changed nothing. Pablo Picasso's "Guernica", first shown in th Paris World's Fair of 1937 did more, drawing the world's attention to the atrocities of the Spanish Civil War. It was also subsequently used to raise funds to support refugees from that conflict.

 

But the real reason this idea comes back to me, though, is the result of a recent visit to Yellowstone National Park. The painter Thomas Moran was invited to join the 1871 Hayden Survey expedition to explore the Yellowstone region, and his paintings of that journey were what ultimately persuaded the U.S.Congress and President Grant to create, in Yellowstone, the world's first national park. The photography of the day was too limited, and of course, colorless, to adequately show the folks back East the grandeur and the unique features of that region. Without the visual interpretations of Moran, it is unlikely much would have happened. The most impressive and influential painting was his first one of the Grand Canyon of the Yellowstone, recorded from what is now called "Artist's Point."

 

National parks now exist worldwide as places of beauty, opportunities for re-creation, and important repositories of biodiversity. Anytime we visit one, we are sharing in a part of Thomas Moran's legacy, a corpus of art work put to positive political and social ends.

Read More

11/3/2015 10:25:50 AM

Completing the Image

James DeBoer / Comment on this

   Good art, I think, should be more about the viewer than about the artist.

 

   At gallery shows, I have often heard visitors standing front of a painting whispering to each other, "What was going through her mind? What was the artist thinking of when she did this?"

 

   Puzzling the viewer isn't the same as engaging the viewer, especially if all you do is simply stimulate a guessing game about the artist and her intentions. Better to involve the viewers in the work itself, and this happens when the viewer sees something of himself in the work. This can be like a mirror, but an Alice in Wonderland mirror that allows you to see your reflection, but also pass through it to somewhere else. In this sense, an image isn't complete until someone else considers it and engages with it. 

 

   Studies have shown that visitors to a public art gallery spend an average of only eight seconds in front of each work of art! How can we extend that time interval for our own works? Perhaps, if as artists, we spent less time portraying our idiosyncrasies and more time exploring our universals, those elements we hold in common with the rest of humankind, and can share through the visual experience of art.

Read More