Ambiguity


Ambiguity - "the quality of being open to more than one interpretation; inexactness" (Oxford)
I find it one of the most attractive things a painting can hold. It can be that the work presents more than one interpretation at the same time and the work can never be completely defined. Or it may be a portrayal of one concept, one thing, but in a way that is indistinct, not fully laid out for us, the viewers, and we must struggle in our minds to complete the picture. It's these kind of paintings that draw me back to a museum to see them again and again, and perhaps you as well.
If everything I've said so far is, itself, ambiguous, then let me show you a couple of paintings. This is, after all, one of the purposes of painting, to show in a picture that which cannot be put well into words.
One of my favorites is Picasso's "The Old Guitarist", which hangs in Chicago's Art Institute. Unfortunately, what is barely visible in reproductions such as above, is the presence of the woman in the painting. She stands behind him, her eyes just above the nape of his neck. The painting has been x-rayed, and the experts tell us that The Old Guitarist is painted over a previous painting containing the woman, and that Picasso was simply reusing an old canvas. In that case, he was sloppy, not doing a very good job of covering over the underlying woman.
But when I stand in front of the actual work, I see where the woman's neck and the guitarist's neck overlap and that Picasso colored the woman's neck a different shade of blue from the guitarist's neck, as though to emphasize her as actually part of the painting we see.
So, Ambiguity #1: Is the presence of the woman in this painting incidental and not really supposed to be there? Or did Picasso reuse the old canvas, and seeing the woman's image seeping through, decide, "I think I'll keep her" and put the lighter shade of blue on her neck? Or perhaps he planned to have her in the picture from the start.
Ambiguity #2: If not just an accident, who then is the woman? Apparently someone the guitarist has on his mind as he picks up his instrument; and old love, a wife, a singer he used to accompany?
All of these interpretations fight with each other in my mind, and I am constantly drawn back to this painting like a bee to honey, unable to resolve them.
In one of my own paintings, I have tried to capture the quality of ambiguity. That is "Edge" (above, pastel, 22" x 30"), which was shown at the International Association of Pastel Societies juried show in Brea, CA, a few years back. While making this painting, the image kept shifting on me: something growing viewed under a microscope? or the surface of a distant planet? or the winds of a desert uncovering the remains of an ancient civilization? There is clearly a difference between the left side of the painting and the right, but where is the actual edge between them? There is no sharp dividing line.
This is like so many things in human experience. We know where things are, generally, but can't exactly say where one stops and another begins. We know what is ocean and what is is land, but where is the exact line between them? The highest reach of the waves? The lowest? At high or low tide? Somewhere in between? Or the line between right and wrong? Some things seem clearly always right or always wrong, but one can usually think of a situation that seems to be an exception and crosses over the line between right and wrong. Although the centers of these categories are clear, the edges are blurry, and therein lies the interest.
Do you have any favorite paintings that possess and indistinctness or ambiguity that you find attractive and draw you to them?
Leave a Comment